I remember reading that in a day at school. It seems like a B grade Eltingville Club ripoff comic, but I did enjoy it since it kept my attention the entire time.
Also reminded me of the early pages of a webcomic I used to read called DubThis!. The set up of the story has a lot of introduction of characters in the Anime Club - which I totally related to. I found the story got a bit too melodramatic for my tastes and I wound up dropping it after a while.