I was introduced to Tenchi Muyou! after I had already been into anime for a few years, so I think the only impact it really had on me was that it was another "thing" I got and another thing to reference with all of my other dorky friends. Maybe it's because I got started with Tenchi TV (Tenchi Universe), maybe being an impatient teenager who could never save a ton of money for an LD player, maybe because it was harder for me to get my hands on JP dialog versions...
I've seen many of the different Tenchi series, though I would say that the only ones that I truly enjoyed were the Ryou-ou-ki OAVs 1& 2, Mihoshi Special, In Love and In Love 2. I dug Tenchi TV enough to finish it once and dive deeper into the franchise but when I went to Daughter of Darkness, Shin Tenchi and GXP ... I knew I was pretty much done and only looked back once.
ryoran wrote:When OAV3 came out, I bought it as soon as it was released...and ended up selling it shortly a week after because I simply couldn't get into it. Even if it was canon and came after the original, it just wasn't the same at all.
This is where I looked back. When Ryou-oh-ki 3 started and made its way to the fansub community, I was excited. I really liked the previous OAVs and knew all about the jumbled timelines and differences between specific series, I thought this would be a "getting back to basics" project. Cash in on some of that nostalgia. I watched an episode or two and just decided that this wasn't even worth downloading. While the harem element had always been present, there had been so much more development in it as a sub-genre since Tenchi originally came out, it came off to me as trying to match the new mold more than trying to re-capture the feel of the original. Since then, I have gladly not looked back.
RE: Tenchi v. UY - I can agree there are a lot of similarities between the two series but the Internet seems to have this hard-on for the two shows being this pinnacle origin of The Harem Genre (TM). Is this a new thing? I'd never seen Urusei Yatsura (or Ranma 1/2 by extension) as a harem show. Tenchi, to me, is that origin - it gives us the concept of a lead that one could insert themselves into by the virtue of him being bland or milquetoast surrounded by a number of girls each with differing yet desirable character traits. UY, to me, is much more your classic sitcom (of The Simpsons variety, as llj nicely put it) where humor utilizes the character relationships: Ataru and anyone with a vagina. To me, Ataru does not have that bland persona, that lack of traits that could make him Joey Fanboy, and that is a critical requirement identifying something as "harem".
greg wrote:all this talk has suddenly given me the urge to buy an LD or two just for the heck of it---especially if they are so cheap.
I hear ya! I go perusing eBay and Craigslist for anime LDs every so often - lots of stuff can still be had for dirt cheap; unfortunately, a lot of the stuff I am most interested in is all more than I am really willing to pay. My legit Macross DYRL LD cost me a third of what my bootleg fansub did (back when I really didn't know much better). I love that this forum also shares the LD love though I guess I shouldn't be too surprised.