I get what you're saying but... Okay, so you said you watched the Black Cauldron, right? Would you think the movie would be more interesting if at the end, it turns out that they really weren't using magic, but they were just all crazy and talking to themselves the whole time? The only movie I've seen in which it turns out that the protagonist is batshit insane and he was deluding himself the whole movie---and it turned out to be great---was Fight Club. I'm sure there are others, but it just doesn't work for the Joan of Arc movie. I guess what I expected from the movie is that it would portray a noble girl doing God's will who was betrayed and martyred. Instead it just turned out to be a psychopath tricking everyone into following her. (Kinda like how the Star Wars prequels turned out.) One makes for a compelling story, and the other turns out to be dull with a throwaway main character, not to mention a heavy-handed dissertation on religion in general, full of eye-rolling 10-year-old-kid type questions like "If God is real, how come bad stuff happens?" I was close to just giving up on the movie, but I decided to stick through with it until the end. Bad move, since apparently I didn't learn my lesson when I watched the first Hulk movie.davemerrill wrote:Didn't really have a problem with her visions being depicted as symptomatic of mental illness- usually when people claim to be doing God's direct bidding, it's because they're crazy, and things don't work out so well for them, or for the rest of us if enough of us happen to be in a less than skeptical mood that day.
I think Jovovich did a good job acting crazy, but I guess her performance during the scenes when she's trying to be normal was a bit lacking. Now all she does is those godawful Resident Evil/Biohazard movies that apparently only liked by Japanese adolescent boys.